The Empty Plate Phenomenon (Doubledays Restaurant Review)

I have lived in Dayton for six years.  For three of those years, I drove past Doubleday’s Grill and Tavern very often (as much as ten times a week going to and from work).  I always wondered if the food was good, but I would often forget to ask the “locals” what they thought.  One day, my husband’s friend told me he had eaten there for lunch.  When asked how the food was, he responded “fantastic!”  I had to go.

I kept forgetting and kept forgetting and then one day, out of the blue, I remembered!  My husband and I walked in and got a table right away.  The first thing we noticed was the enormity of the restaurant.  It didn’t look like much from the outside, but the inside seemed to go on and on and on.  The second thing we noticed was the enormity of the menu!  It also went on and on!  I remember taking Carolyn here one time only to remember she panics when she has so many choices in front of her.  Not too smart on my part!  (View full menu here.)

They have so much to offer I can’t remember all the things I’ve tried, though I have a couple favorites I have ordered more than once.  If you don’t know this about me, I am a creature of repeat ordering.  I really try not to be, especially in a place like this where you can’t seem to get a bad meal, but if I find something I like, I end up ordering it over and over again.

Tonight was no exception.  I had a craving for a burger with bacon (surprise, surprise) so that’s what I went with.

Jeff, deciding to try something new, ordered the BLT pizza. Doubleday’s has their very own pizza parlor type add on to the restaurant called Monster Pizza.  They have many different types of pizza including “Bride of BLT”, “Italian Werewolf”, and “It Came From Outer Greece”.  Great names, great flavors, what more can you ask for?

There is one stipulation in my book for going to Doubleday’s.  The potato soup, complete with cheese and bacon, must be ordered.

There are two types of potato soup in the world, my friends: the cheese laden version and the creamy, wonderful, melt in your mouth version.  You can guess which one this is.  While there is nothing wrong with the cheesy version, I prefer my potato soup “plain”.  Too much cheese overpowers the wonderful flavors of the potato.

Take this into consideration: I do not eat at restaurants by myself very often.  I will go to Panera and sometimes City BBQ by myself, but never to a restaurant that has servers.  A few days after I sampled this wonderful concoction of potatoes, cream, butter, and other ingredients, I ended up back at the restaurant at 11:30a on a Tuesday, Harry Potter book in hand, to eat alone.  It was the best day ever.  Just me, Harry, and a vat bowl of potato soup.

It’s always a sad feeling when the potato soup bowl runs dry.

The Empty Plate Phenomenon occurs on a very rare basis.  It’s about as common as Hailey’s Comet.  It’s been documented and studied with no scientific conclusions made.  Basically, every time Jeff and I go out to eat, I end up taking home a to go box.  I never, ever finish my entire meal.  I have been like this since I was a little girl.  Every so often, however, I *gasp* finish an entire meal out!

Tonight, I brought my big girl panties to the table.  I ate my entire cup of soup (very filling, mind you) and my entire (8 oz…yes I know it’s not huge) Bacon Cheddar burger.  In record time.  I think from the time the plate hit the table to the time I finished, Jeff had eaten 1.5 pieces of pizza.

The burger wasn’t phenomenal (I would definitely go to Five Guys or Sammy’s if given the choice), but it was still good!  The burger patty itself was just that…a patty.  I believe it was a traditional frozen patty they thawed and threw on a hot grill.  I could be wrong, but that’s how it tasted.  As I said, though, the burger was still quite tasty.  I’m not sure I would order it again, but I had no trouble finishing it tonight.  If you want to get something really tasty, go with the French Dip grinder.  YUM!

As I said, Jeff and I have never had a bad meal here.  Their salads are even good!  Put it this way…I have always wanted to try their dessert, but I never have room for it. If you’re in the Centerville area, stop in for a bite!

Doubleday’s Grill and Tavern
199 E Alex Bell Road
Dayton, Ohio

Doubleday's Grill & Tavern on Urbanspoon


9 thoughts on “The Empty Plate Phenomenon (Doubledays Restaurant Review)

  1. I live very close to Doubledays and we go a couple of times a month probably! It is delicious. I love the potato soup, the voodoo veggie pizza is also to die for! The ranch dressing alone makes Doubledays worth a stop!

    • I don’t know that I’ve ever had the ranch dressing and I KNOW I’ve never had the veggie pizza. I’ll have to give both a try! Do you have any other favorite restaurants in Dayton?

      • We love El Toro which is in a few locations. Other than that I feel like we eat at regular chain restuarants. We have some friends that really like Archers on 48 in Centerville but we haven’t been yet.

  2. Next time you go, make sure you try the Pretzel Bites with spinach con queso dip, Baked Buffalo Chicken Pasta (sounds weird but it is AMAZING!) and if you like Greek food the “It Came from Outer Greece” pizza. Love Doubledays!

    • I actually JUST had the Pretzel Bites a few weeks ago! My friend and I tried them for the first time and we both decided we hadn’t lived until we tried these little nuggets of heaven!

      My husband and I love Greek, so we will have to get that pizza some time. Thanks for the tip!

  3. We are going to have to check out those pretzels! We love soft pretzels so that sounds amazing. Too bad we can’t go tonight…..:)

    Shelly – what other Centerville/Dayton restaurants do you recommend?

  4. We love Flavors Eatery in Centerville (just like Boro Bistro with a few different menu options), Amelia’s Bistro in Bellbrook (for lunch/dinner), Blueberry Cafe in Bellbrook (for breakfast), Bahn Mai Thai Cafe in Centerville (I personally think it is better than Thai 9 downtown & way more convenient), North China in Centerville, and Archer’s Tavern in Centerville (just opened about 6 months ago near where the new Kroger Marketplace is under construction)… just a few of my faves!

  5. I’ve been wondering if Doubledays was worth a shot and now I’ll have to stop in! We have company coming in this weekend, so maybe in the next few days we’ll have to go there. Shelly – great restaurant recs. My husband and I are always looking for new places to try out around Dayton. We haven’t been too impressed with the restaurant selection so far.

    • It’s definitely company worthy. I took my dad and stepmom there a few weeks ago when they visited. My husband and I just tried a new restaurant, House of Thai, in Miamisburg that I really liked.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s